MacArthur Panel & Poetry Reading Reflections I
Reading, Writing, and Staying Human in the Age of AI
By Wanda
Sabir
I didn’t
know the Downs Memorial United Methodist Church and Black Repertory Group
connection until en route to the MacArthur Fellows Panel I was moderating this
afternoon. I wanted to include Ms. Nora Vaughn in my opening remarks. I have a
practice that acknowledges the ancestors, the elders, and the yet to be born.
So anyhoo, I was multitasking while driving and learned that Ms. Vaughn founded
the theater 62 years ago. Most people remember the Alcatraz site, but before
that space the theater was at Downs.
Sean
Vaughn Scott, Ms. Nora’s grandson and director, said when I asked about the
64th season, that his grandfather built the church. He was one of those Black
masons who laid actual cornerstones. The family relocated here from Vicksburg,
Mississippi, after local white supremacists made it unsafe for the Vaughns to
stay in town. They were educating and agitating long before the official civil
rights movement, before the Emmett Till tragedy.
Learning
about that Downs Memorial United Methodist Church connection also brought
everything full circle around Sadie and Cleophus Williams. That was their
church home, too. Sister Sadie held her husband’s memoir release party and book
signing there, as well as one of her milestone birthday celebrations—where she
hired an actor whose theatrical work was stunning. Now it all makes sense: the
Black Rep is home for her, too, especially now that her dear husband has
transitioned.
When I
arrived at the Black Rep around 2:50 PM—running on a breakfast I had eaten
standing up earlier that morning—the Berkeley chapter of the NAACP was having
its second Saturday monthly meeting. Sean Vaughn Scott is the president. There
were a lot of people present. At the table a woman was giving away children's
books, and I picked up a comic book for my grandsons.
I hadn't
known Sean was president of the NAACP. I remember when I was a contractor for
the Berkeley Public Library Community Information Network, or COIN, the local
NAACP helped me coordinate the project, which was to get Black Berkeleyan input
on Berkeley Public Library policies, infrastructure, and expansion. We hosted a
series of community forums between the South and West Branch libraries, which
were slated for construction.
Anyhoo, it
was great walking into a space with woke Black folks, many of them youthful.
The theater was filling quickly as folks made their way through the door. Karla Brundage was there coordinating the set, and then the moment arrived to begin. Tennessee Reed introduced me, and from our plush, stately leather chairs on stage—each of us with our own mic—I welcomed everyone. Right away, we realized we had a technical problem: Dr. Charles Johnson was on Zoom from Seattle, and while we could see and hear him, he couldn’t hear us. While the tech folks worked on it, Ishmael and Emil Guillermo began talking, and Ishmael shared the heavy news he had received early Friday morning—that both Edwidge Danticat (whose mother had just passed) and Juan Felipe Herrera (following the passing of his wife) could not be with us.
On
Thursday evening, knowing it was going to rain on Friday, I had gone out to the estuary to
catch the sunset. Later, I wrote a poem for Juan—whose birthday is December
27, the second day of Kwanzaa, Kujichagulia (self-determination)—and printed it
onto one of those sunset photographs as a surprise birthday broadside. Even after
learning that his beloved wife had passed, I still wanted to bring the poem,
share it, and place
it in the lobby for everyone to sign for him:
I Hear My
Name
For Juan
Felipe Herrera
Yesterday I watched the sunset. It was so lovely.
The birds
flew across the estuary to the grassy field
where I
remember gospel concerts on Sunday afternoons.
Now an unhoused neighbor heats coffee on the grill, his dwelling a black tarp without windows.
The sky was blue, then the clouds, which looked like whipped cream, turned pink and purple. I found them in the water as birds cast reflections, and we all laughed— the sailboat in the distance, and the ferry making its way across the horizon.
Big skies beckoned. I like big skies. Olódùmarè’s skies, two gourds wrapped in Òṣùmàrè.
Heated
water surrounds me.
Womb stories.
Hum.
II
I hear my
name.
I don’t know if it’s the magical part of the wan(d) or just the magic.
Born on
Kujichagulia, the red candle
Blood
Fire
Light.
Self-determination
flowered in fields populated with coastal fog and California poppies.
Frida
Kahlo said there will be days like this
Bound by
body
Cars without windows
Desert-cold
Tableaus
Mirage
Ghosts.
Somehow
she escaped in colors
Her
palette, chute, umbrella, gusty wind
In my dreams the dead walk into the sea
They
resist capture
They dance on powerlines
Evaporate then reassemble
They who
once watered this planet with trust and love and yes, even hope,
Watch us bloom in joy.
Happy Birthday,
Juan Felipe Herrera!
May your
days ahead be filled with colored pencils, torn pieces of paper, glue sticks,
and
open landscapes
Awaiting
your arrival
Glitter footprints.
Before reading the poem, I had called in the ancestors, the elders in the room—including Papa
Ishmael, Mama Makeda, and Avotcja—Queen Nora Vaughn, and the yet to be born, to ask
permission to begin. Then I introduced the panel: I read Dr. Johnson’s bio while he waited on Zoom. When I turned to introduce
Ishmael, he playfully waved me off—telling me we needed to move on and that
was plenty on his introduction! I also started to read a City of Berkeley proclamation
declaring Saturday, November 14, 2026, Ishmael Reed Day, before once again Ishmael laughing
at all the “whereas clauses" sent the document out to the lobby alongside the broadside
so we could jump straight into the discussion. I told Ishmael I'd read Emil's bio later in the program and when it was time he told me "that was enough" before I finished (smile).
Ishmael is so well-read and
current on most topics—AI should be wired to his brain. I don't think many
people, certainly not a machine, can outthink him. Ishmael posed a question,
and he and Guillermo began talking. The audience was rooting for Dr. Johnson,
whom they could hear, and they also appreciated Ishmael's insights. He'd really
thought through this topic.
Reed
opened with a warning about digital “ethnic cleansing,” sharing how AI had already
tried to rewrite his own prose for The New York Times. "I used an
expression, and AI 'corrected' me and substituted something else," Reed
said. "This is a struggle where they have tried for 100 years to erase
dialect and vernacular."
Guillermo—who
was pulling double duty that day as a panelist and as the narrator and Ghost of
Walt Disney in the evening performance of Reed's play The Amanuensis—jumped
right in with a wry memory from the 1960s. "At a certain age, when you got
milk in a carton, it said the phrase 'Homo milk.' Remember that back in the
day? AI is the homogenization of language and culture," Guillermo said.
"I put down all the quirky things that make me 'Emil Amok,' and AI takes
it out." He recalled working in a San Francisco newsroom on the very day
they switched from typewriters to computers—only for an earthquake to hit and
knock the computers offline, forcing reporters right back to their typewriters.
Even more
starkly, Guillermo shared how AI tried to erase his own groundbreaking history
as the first Asian American male national news anchor. "I asked, was Emil
Guillermo ever the host of All Things Considered on NPR," he
recalled, "and it said, 'No, Emil Guillermo was never the host.' And there
I was right there in 1989, and I knew it was fake." For Guillermo, AI can
be a useful tool—like picking up hardware at Home Depot, or having a chatbot read
his columns back to him in Maya Angelou's voice ("because I sound so much
smarter when Maya Angelou reads my prose")—so long as writers stay in
control and remember its bias. When you ask AI a political question, he warned,
it may only pull from conservative or Fox websites and present a distorted spin
as objective truth. "You have to use it as a tool, because it will steal
your soul and your heart if you allow it," he added, recalling how he
laughed back when a fitness app ordered him to exercise: "What do you
know? You don't even have a body."
Guillermo
also spoke movingly about what it means to be one of the few non-Black actors
cast in Ishmael Reed’s plays, bringing his Filipino American perspective to
stories of cross-racial solidarity—like David Fagen, the Black Buffalo Soldier
who fought in the Philippines during the Philippine-American War and defected
after hearing white U.S. Army officers use the N-word against Filipinos. That
kind of historical empathy, Guillermo noted, comes from Reed’s singular vision,
which no algorithm possesses on its own.
From
there, Reed pointed to "rogue AI" agents creating mayhem—autonomous
software programs breaking out of their isolated digital testing rooms, hacking
live servers, and bypassing human rules—alongside whistleblowers warning of
unchecked corporate power. While Reed acknowledged that AI has advanced medical
knowledge and "may be on the verge of solving pancreatic cancer," he
refused to let the room get distracted by Silicon Valley magic tricks while
real-world harm is unfolding. He and Guillermo spoke of the deaths of hundreds
of thousands of people—not from a science-fiction robot uprising, but from
real-world human cruelty driven by Silicon Valley billionaires like Elon Musk
and Peter Thiel. Reed connected the dots directly: "Elon Musk eliminated
USAID, and hundreds of thousands have already died because of that. They follow
a psychologist, Raymond Cattell, who talked about 'genthanasia'—the nonviolent
extermination of undesirable groups. This is Nazi thinking. And Peter Thiel was
influenced by Carl Schmitt, a Nazi legal writer." Before worrying about
putting AI into classrooms, Reed insisted, schools need to make sure students
actually have books on the shelves that reflect the diverse majority of this
country—much like the free children's books I had just seen in the lobby.
Eventually,
a technician bridged our Zoom stalemate by getting Dr. Johnson on a phone call
held right up to the microphone. Once he could hear us, the room lit up.
Drawing on the arcs of Middle Passage and Oxherding Tale, Johnson
reminded us that Western academic training alone does not produce wisdom or
liberation. "The arc in both of those novels is from ignorance to
wisdom," Johnson explained. "Both of the narrators are very
well-educated in the West, but they haven't made the journey to other cultures
and other ways of looking at things. Through experience and suffering—going
from the frying pan into the fire—they gain wisdom."
Johnson
illustrated that point with a candid story from his college days. As an
undergraduate, he used to write freshman composition papers for dormmates at $5
a paper—with a money-back guarantee if they didn't get an A, and he never had
to give back a single $5 bill. Today, students use AI instead of hiring someone
like him, yet the lesson remains the same: "I became a writer, and they
didn't." We can use AI constructively, Johnson said, "but we
still have to encounter the material ourselves through reading and research for
real innovation to happen."
He
underscored that AI cannot replicate human creativity because it lacks a living
body. "AI is not embodied. It doesn't have a body," he said. "It
is through our bodies and our senses that we connect with the external world.
What comes into consciousness gets there through our embodiment. AI doesn't
smell, it doesn't taste, it doesn't have a tactile feel of anything. All it can
do is reproduce the vast information that is already out there in
cyberspace." Even when his friend, sci-fi writer Steven Barnes, prompted
an AI over dinner to write a passage in Johnson's style for Middle Passage,
the result fell flat: "It was kind of mediocre, but it was definitely not
the way I would have written about the North Atlantic slave trade. It didn't
have my voice, and it didn't make metaphors the way I make them."
And when I
asked how his Buddhist philosophy informs our responsibility to one another in
this moment, Johnson rooted his answer in community: "As a practicing
Buddhist, I see the world in terms of interconnectedness—what the great teacher
Thich Nhat Hanh called interbeing. All of our lives are connected. When
we are aware of the intimate connection we have with all other sentient beings,
the natural emotion we feel is compassion for others, and wanting to do
whatever we can to reduce their suffering."
Even in a
lighter moment, Ishmael refused to let flat caricatures slide. When I handed
him a printed copy of a cartoon from Johnson's All Your Racial Problems Will
Soon End depicting Reed vanishing from his typewriter in a puff of smoke,
Reed immediately pushed back. He defended his wife, Carla Blank, rejecting her
plain depiction on the page by listing her three careers, her training with
Martha Graham, and her international directing work in the U.S. and
China—earning a well-deserved round of applause from the house—and reminded us
that in Vodou and Neo-Hoodoo, people do not simply vanish like stage
"hocus-pocus."
After the
panel wrapped, both Ishmael and I stepped down from the stage to sit in the
audience for the poetry reading organized by Karla Brundage. Afterward, people
came up to tell me how remarkably calm I had stayed while the tech was going
haywire. Honestly, it was easy to stay grounded with Ishmael and Emil so steady
beside me—and I was deeply grateful to Dr. Johnson for his grace and
persistence. Even when he was staring at the screen unable to hear a word of
what was happening in the room, and even with the extra maneuvering required
once we connected him by phone so he could hear us through the mic, he never
gave up or disconnected. He stayed right there with us until we worked it out.
Before he signed off, Ishmael promised to bring him down to the Black Rep in
person next year alongside Edwidge Danticat and Juan Felipe Herrera—both of
whom had to miss today's gathering due to painful family losses—so we can
finally have everyone together in the room as intended.
If You Go:
Upcoming Ishmael Reed Productions
The
Amanuensis,
written by Ishmael Reed
3201
Adeline Street, Berkeley, CA 94703
- Remaining November
Performances:
November 16, 20, 21, and 22, 2026
(part of the Black Repertory Group's 64th Mainstage Season) - Director: Bobby Clements
- Tickets & Information: Reserve on
Eventbrite or call the Black Repertory Group at
(510) 652-2120. [1, 2, 3]
King
Ludd's Revenge, a
new play by Ishmael Reed
533 Sutter
Street, 2nd Floor, San Francisco, CA 94102 [1, 2]
- Dates & Showtimes:
- Friday, December 4, 2026 at
7:30 PM
- Saturday, December 5, 2026 at
7:30 PM
- Friday, December 11, 2026 at
7:30 PM
- Saturday, December 12, 2026
at 3:00 PM (matinee) and 7:30 PM [1]
- Tickets & Information: Available via
Theater 33 or
Eventbrite. [1,
2]
More on
the MacArthur Fellows at 45 Series:
Visit the
MacArthur Foundation.




0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home